Natural Law Energy’s (NLE) planned investment was billed by TC as the biggest-ever indigenous investment in an oil project, highlighting how some communities are seeking to share in the industry’s profits while others oppose it.
Adding indigenous support may help efforts by Canada and TC to convince U.S. President-elect Joe Biden not to revoke the permit of the $8-billion Keystone XL when he takes office as he has promised.
If they are successful, millions of dollars will flow over a generation into indigenous communities to help youth afford university or pay for business investments, said Chief Alvin Francis of Nekaneet First Nation in Saskatchewan, one of five involved in NLE.
“It’s about making life better for all of our youth,” Francis said.
“If I could meet Joe Biden I’d say, ‘This a chance for you to change my First Nation’s view of the world.’”
TC proposed KXL 12 years ago and the project has since run into a steady series of legal and political obstacles, opposed by some U.S. tribes, landowners and environmental activists.
Nekaneet, a community of about 540 people, has never been involved in a deal of this scale, having previously developed a strip mall.
It joined four First Nations – Ermineskin, Akamihk, Louis Bull Tribe and Little Pine – to form NLE. The coalition has attracted interest from banks in financing TC’s project, given that much of its shipping capacity is already under contract, said NLE director Brian Mountain. He declined to identify the banks.
“What we’re doing is creating intergenerational wealth,” Mountain said.
NLE is talking with Alberta Indigenous Opportunities Corp, a provincial corporation, about guaranteeing some of the loans, he said.
Spokespeople for Canada’s six big banks declined to comment or did not respond. There is precedent for banks supporting indigenous investments in energy, such as a C$545 million bond issue for two bands in 2017 to invest in a Suncor Energy Inc storage facility.
Financing is set to close in the third quarter next year, likely well after Biden clarifies his position on KXL, easing risk for the First Nations, said Ken Coates, a professor of public policy at University of Saskatchewan.
Francis said while there is risk Biden will quash KXL, he is optimistic his position will soften.
He said he asked TC in 2017 for a benefits-sharing agreement that would last KXL’s lifetime. TC balked, but in late 2019 it contacted Francis and asked if Nekaneet would buy a stake.
That began a year of negotiations and development of the coalition.
Under the deal, TC would give NLE a stake and pay it a prescribed annual return in exchange for NLE raising funds and investing them in KXL, Mountain said.
NLE would use the proceeds to repay loans for its investment and provide cash to its First Nations for 30 years.
The payments will be based on KXL’s revenues. Mountain and TC declined to estimate the payments’ value and TC did not confirm NLE’s account of the deal’s structure, saying it was confidential.
For TC, the investment allows the company to tie up less of its own capital, after recently selling a stake in its Coastal GasLink pipeline to private equity.
The partnership reflects TC’s commitment to sharing KXL’s benefits with indigenous communities in both Canada and the United States, company spokesman Terry Cunha said.
Some oppose new pipelines for the toll fossil fuels have on the environment.
“Destroying the planet to make money is unconscionable, no matter who is making the money,” said Steve Volker, lawyer for U.S.-based Indigenous Environmental Network.