Cement association takes aim at B.C.’s decision to bypass 2020 Building Code
The Cement Association of Canada (CAC) has expressed surprise that the B.C. government is bypassing the ongoing 2020 National Building Code of Canada (“NBCC”) processes, allowing municipalities to issue building permits for encapsulated mass timber construction (EMTC) up to 12 storeys.
The Building Code review process is not yet complete. Of greatest concern, especially in the context of high seismic zones in BC, is that there are, as of yet, no approved seismic design specifications for 12 storey cross-laminated timber buildings in the 2020 NBCC. These discussions are currently ongoing and recommendations will not be approved until later this year.
“While the B.C. Government’s intent to increase market share for B.C. wood products is understandable, and while the Cement Association supports the Horgan Government’s actions to address a severe affordable housing situation, allowing municipalities to approve 12 storey encapsulated mass timber construction in the absence of approved seismic specifications for this form of construction is premature,” says Michael McSweeney, president and CEO of the CAC. “These discussions are currently ongoing and no decision or recommendations for the use of encapsulated mass timber construction has been made by the NBCC.”
There is a significant amount of evidence available that refutes wood industry claims about tall wood building safety, earthquake resistance, resilient construction and environmental performance that needs to be closely examined in a transparent way, adds McSweeney.
“Canada’s codes and standards system is the envy of the world and all governments should support the development of rigorous codes that hold the trust of the people and protect its citizens,” he says.
Setting aside the wood industry’s environmental claims, which are increasingly called into question by academics, national environmental groups and building professionals, McSweeney further states that “in the majority of towns where we see lumber mills, we also see sand pits, quarries and ready mixed concrete plants, so the government’s action is simply ‘robbing Peter to pay Paul’, shifting jobs, rather than creating new ones.
“Governments should not be in the business of picking ‘winners or losers’ over competing building materials.”
McSweeney is calling on the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing to urgently meet with all members of the building materials industry and to put an immediate pause on any regulations for 12 storey encapsulated mass timber buildings which, at this time, bypass the work of the 2020 National Building Code Seismic Committee whose deliberations are currently ongoing with no recommendations finalized.
Multi-storey mass timber proponents often cite the University of British Columbia’s Brock Commons Building, which they deem an excellent example of a tall wood building. McSweeney wants to set the record straight.
“UBC’s Brock Commons is in truth a composite building, with a significant amount of reinforced concrete used for the foundation, the ground floor podium, the twin elevator shafts and pre-cast concrete stairwells that form the concrete cores,” he says. “The cross-laminated timber relies on the stiff concrete cores for stability. Without concrete, the building would not be able to support itself. In addition, concrete was used to cover the wood floors and two layers of heavy fire resistant drywall were applied to encapsulate all of the wood construction.”